top of page
Search

Honestly

Writer: Mennonite Women USA
Mennonite Women USA
10 minutes ago
3 min read

How do we live with the ache, the persistent longing of every day? That’s the big question that Kate Bowler wrestles with in her newest book, Joyful Anyway. After surviving stage-four colon cancer, Bowler reflects on her expectation that she should be constantly grateful. Everything should now be wonderful. If only she were a better, more spiritual person, but somehow she still feels the ache. 


Kate writes about joining a book club for highly sensitive people—people who are sensitive to everyone’s needs around them but tend to neglect their own needs. There is a discussion of the gifts and pitfalls of being so keenly aware of others' needs, but she only sees the pitfalls, the results of self-neglect. “There must be a gentler path to love, love of others, love of ourselves. All I know is whenever I have tried, it has felt strange and selfish and wrong to get back what I have given (p. 114)."


I can relate to Bowler’s statement. For me, as my children have moved out of the house, I am finally enjoying the freedom to choose what I will do with my time, rather than feeling obligated to attend every event at school and be at every church activity. However, I sometimes feel guilty for choosing to do things that only benefit or please myself. I get this feeling that I’m not a very nice or kind person like I used to think I was.


Bowler notes that this is often a trait that is expected of women: to take care of others' needs before their own. She realizes that she is or has been a willing participant in this pattern in her life and it feels like a comfortable place to be. Yet it leads to resentment of those she loves most. In order for things to change, everyone would need to change, including herself.


As an historian, Bowler studies modern religious communities and their ideas of health, wealth, and the American dream. Can we be happy, if we are being truly honest with ourselves? How do we move on from difficult circumstances? She writes about the need to first mourn all that we will not do, be, or see. We need to be honest about our disappointments.


Then we can start looking for joy in unexpected places at unexpected times. We can learn to be open to the possibility of joy, even in the midst of grief. Sometimes it requires recognizing the absurdity of life, surprising us in the most unlikely moments. Kate shares a post-surgery story of asking the hospital intern to pretend he was doing a magic trick while he removed a tube from her stomach. He played along with it and the result was a moment of hilarity and joy that stuck with Bowler and made me laugh out loud as I read it.


Is it possible to set ourselves up to experience more joy in our lives? Kate tests this question by choosing to do things that involve some reasonable danger like jumping off cliffs and swimming with sharks. And it works, sometimes. Her advice is to take a chance, change your routine, and be open to a new perspective.


Sprinkled throughout the book are Lists that Bowler has collected from online, from kids, and from people that she knows. Things like "What Causes the Ache," "Microjoys," "Surprising Moments Other People Have Found Joy," among others. 


Bowler’s characteristic honesty and absurd sense of humor shine throughout the book as she shares a vulnerability that makes me tear up, because I also know the ache and the instinct to pretend that everything is good, all the time. But I also find unexpected moments of joy in the midst of the everyday-ness of life.


The reader is left with no assurances of perpetually sunny days, no promises of rainbows and ponies but with a knowing that in the midst of difficult days, glimpses of joy will find us.


Heather Myers

PEACE Mennonite Fellowship

Archbold, Ohio


***

Mennonite Women USA values what all women have to say, and Women's Voices blog is a space to honor their words.

Posts are reviewed for tolerance and respect but don't necessarily reflect MW USA's official position.


Women's Voices blog is a community journal published monthly. Read the archives for past reflections by diverse women: https://www.mennonitewomenusa.org/blog and consider offering a piece about your own story, ministry, or book analysis: https://www.mennonitewomenusa.org/post/call-for-writers.

 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page